Cameras in care homes are ‘expensive, laborious and ineffective’, says Stephen Burke

Posted on October 8th, by geoff in Caring Times. Comments Off on Cameras in care homes are ‘expensive, laborious and ineffective’, says Stephen Burke

Caring Times Latest

While the Care Quality Commission is to offer guidance to families on how to use secret cameras to monitor their loved ones in care, Stephen Burke, director of Good Care Guide (, the TripAdvisor style website for the care industry, believes that installing cameras in care homes is a “terrible idea” and “a step too far”.

“Surveillance is not the answer; it undermines staff and implies that they can’t be trusted,” said Mr Burke.

“There have been a number of devastating cases of abuse at care homes lately but there are better ways to avoid these in the future. The CQC needs to be more responsive to families’ concerns and tackle the early signs of poor care before it’s too late.

“The key to improving care is not by introducing a Big Brother-style culture but to ensure the industry is well inspected, regulated and staff are properly trained, supervised and managed while punishing those who provide inadequate care.

“What the industry really needs is better funding from the grassroots up; investing in training staff properly, rewarding them for their good work, and monitoring them regularly by inspectors who know the warning signs. Installing cameras will prove expensive, laborious, ineffective and shift the focus away from what care providers are there for – providing excellent care 24 hours a day.”

The CQC plans to issue its guidance on the use of secret cameras at the end of October.

Comments are closed.

Latest blog posts

Flu jabs – a vexed question

By Caring Times editor GEOFF HODGSON

As the days grow shorter and temperatures fall, the annual anxiety about ‘flu and whether or not to be vaccinated...

Health & social care integration – an epic quest of the 21st Century

By Caring Times editor GEOFF HODGSON

For centuries, marine explorers sought to find a ‘North West Passage’ whereby ships could travel from the North Atlantic, across...

Getting it right – all the time

By guest blogger JEF SMITH

It is a truism that the sort of care residents receive varies very substantially between homes; on this point Care...