This year, next year, sometime, never?


Posted on December 29th, by geoff in CT blog. 1 Comment

By guest blogger JOHN BURTON

In December, after their savage questioning of the chief executive and the Department of Health Permanent Secretary, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) reported that CQC was “not yet an effective regulator”. True. Six years ago, in the run-up to the 2010 general election, I published an article anticipating that CQC would be swept away by a new government in the promised “bonfire of the quangos”. I set out a scheme for the effective localised inspection of social care.

My prediction was wrong. CQC was not only preserved, it was expanded. Under very poor direction, it failed spectacularly, and the Public Accounts Committee (among others) ripped it to pieces. The top management was eventually prised out, protesting to the last that it wasn’t their fault.

Instead of rethinking the whole thing, ministers and the Department of Health persisted with a fundamentally flawed design and no clear purpose, and appointed new managers and board to make it work. However, while the new management have tried their best to improve it, after three years of effort, it still doesn’t work. And it never will.

No matter what CQC do (and they never say no to taking on more), regulation and inspection are going in the wrong direction, taking the whole of social care with them. Unfortunately, the better it becomes at going in the wrong direction, the further from the right destination it gets.

The board of CQC has a new Chair. At the December board meeting CQC was still reeling from the PAC verdict, but the new incumbent had not yet taken up his position. We now have another chance to change direction and, for all I know, that may be why Jeremy Hunt has chosen this particular person. If not, we will have to wait until, as before, some terrible public scandal of poorly inspected care blasts open an opportunity for real change. Then we must summon the courage, vision and determination to make the change. The costs of timid collusion are a thousand times bigger than the proposed new fees. Let’s not fail again.

  • The CT Blog is written in a personal capacity – comments and opinions expressed are not necessarily endorsed or supported by Caring Times.




One response to “This year, next year, sometime, never?”

  1. Bob Ferguson says:

    New year, new resolution, same old answer

    Was it really six years ago? My, doesn’t time fly when you’re having fun? Keep on flogging that dead horse, John. One day the combined might of Whitehall is bound to recognise they have got it so badly wrong and that your way is the only true way. But it may not be in this century!


Latest blog posts

An upgraded Better Care Fund: game changing or game playing?

By Guest Blogger BOB FERGUSON

You’ll have heard few cheers for the Better Care Fund (BCF), the bright idea intended to nudge the NHS and...

Clear thinking on care funding

By Guest Blogger JEF SMITH

In the rarified atmosphere of political debate engendered by the general election, social care is only just about hanging on....

Enabling our most venerable voters

By Caring Times editor GEOFF HODGSON

I wonder if any former politicians are now living in care homes. I also wonder if any of them might...