Cats, pigeons and quantum meruit


Posted on August 26th, by geoff in CT blog. Comments Off on Cats, pigeons and quantum meruit

By Caring Times editor Geoff Hodgson

‘Quantum meruit’, an arcane legal term meaning, roughly, a fair return for services rendered, gained currency in the care sector in the late 1990s. Now, after a decade of quiescence, it looks like it might be making a comeback.

In recent years when, in the face of local authorities’ refusal to negotiate on fees, despairing care providers have turned to litigation, judicial review has been the orthodox route. Providers had enjoyed a fair degree of success in judicial reviews until a recent decision in Northumberland gave more weight than had previously been given to local authorities’ discretionary powers. Well, it had been fun while it lasted.

Enter Abbeyfield, a not-for-profit provider unhappy with the tricksiness of Newcastle City Council when the time came for another look at the contract. Abandoning judicial review, Abbeyfield’s lawyers invoked private law, arguing about contractual obligations. It worked.

The judge went much further than telling Newcastle to go away and have a think about what rate it should be paying (the best a provider could reasonably expect from a judicial review), he ordered the council to pay more, going so far as to set the fees. High-fives all round at Abbeyfield.

The case begs a lot of questions, two of which are: will we see similar challenges from providers? And what strategies might local authorities adopt? Perhaps they’ll begin to engage more meaningfully with independent providers. The October issue of Caring Times features a lawyer’s assessment of the potential significance of the Newcastle decision. Worth a read, I’d say.

  • The CT Blog is written in a personal capacity – comments and opinions expressed are not necessarily endorsed or supported by Caring Times.




Comments are closed.


Latest blog posts

The NHS and all that jazz

By Caring Times editor GEOFF HODGSON

Last week the National Health Service marked its 70th anniversary. The irony is that, when this all too human institution...

The bland leaving the bland?

By guest blogger JEF SMITH

The headline for an interview which Sir David Behan, the Care Quality Commission’s departing chief executive, gave to The Guardian...

IT comes to CQC

By guest blogger JOHN BURTON

This month, IT is coming to CQC in person. David Behan is leaving, and DB’s replacement is IT, Ian Trenholm...