Staff dismissal – a fair procedure is everything


Posted on March 1st, by editor in Caring Times. No Comments

A recent Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) decision in the case of Kelly-Madden v Manor Surgery (EAT 0105/6) has resolved the uncertainty of whether or not a decision to dismiss an employee can be ruled unfair. The case concerned Ms Kelly-Madden who was employed as the practice manager of Manor Surgery. She was dismissed for paying herself unauthorised overtime payments. The employer committed a number of errors in dealing with Ms Kelly-Madden’s dismissal, including failing to question key people about Ms Kelly-Madden’s assertions and, when she appealed against her dismissal, her appeal was conducted by the partner who had been involved in the original decision to dismiss her. Ms Kelly-Madden brought a claim for unfair dismissal on the grounds of the inadequacy of the dismissal procedure followed by the employer. The Employment Tribunal (ET) looked at the circumstances in which the decision to dismiss was made and found that it was substantially fair even though, overall, the procedure followed was not fai





Comments are closed.


Latest blog posts

Time for a ten dollar answer

By Caring Times editor GEOFF HODGSON

Ernest Hemingway was known for his minimalist style and he used to pooh-pooh what he called “ten-dollar” words. Not to...

Lacking capacity

By guest blogger JEF SMITH

A friend of mine diagnosed with cancer – now, happily, treated – was asked how he could possibly have missed the...

Care homes – understated examples of tasteful design

By Caring Times editor GEOFF HODGSON

Dozens of recently-built care homes are material proof that it is perfectly possible to design aesthetically pleasing buildings and put...